| 2009 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Mark Sanchez | Southern Cal |
| 3 | Shonn Greene | Iowa |
| 6 | Matt Slauson | Nebraska |
| 2008 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Vernon Gholston | Ohio State |
| 1 | Dustin Keller | Purdue |
| 4 | Dwight Lowery | San Jose State |
| 5 | Erik Ainge | Tennessee |
| 6 | Marcus Henry | Kansas |
| 7 | Nate Garner | Arkansas |
| 2007 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Darrelle Revis | Pittsburgh |
| 2 | David Harris | Michigan |
| 6 | Jacob Bender | Nicholls State |
| 7 | Chansi Stuckey | Clemson |
| 2006 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | D'Brickashaw Ferguson | Virginia |
| 1 | Nick Mangold | Ohio State |
| 2 | Kellen Clemens | Oregon |
| 3 | Anthony Schlegel | Ohio State |
| 3 | Eric Smith | Michigan State |
| 4 | Brad Smith | Missouri |
| 4 | Leon Washington | Florida State |
| 5 | Jason Pociask | Wisconsin |
| 6 | Drew Coleman | Texas Christian |
| 7 | Titus Adams | Nebraska |
| 2005 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 2 | Mike Nugent | Ohio State |
| 2 | Justin Miller | Clemson |
| 3 | Sione Pouha | Utah |
| 4 | Kerry Rhodes | Louisville |
| 5 | Andre Maddox | North Carolina State |
| 6 | Cedric Houston | Tennessee |
| 6 | Joel Dreessen | Colorado State |
| 7 | Harry Williams | Tuskegee |
| 2004 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Jonathan Vilma | Miami (FL) |
| 3 | Derrick Strait | Oklahoma |
| 4 | Jerricho Cotchery | North Carolina State |
| 4 | Adrian Jones | Kansas |
| 5 | Erik Coleman | Washington State |
| 6 | Marko Cavka | Sacramento State |
| 7 | Darrell McClover | Miami (FL) |
| 7 | Trevor Johnson | Nebraska |
| 7 | Derrick Ward | Ottawa (KS) |
| 7 | Rashad Washington | Kansas State |
| 2003 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Dewayne Robertson | Kentucky |
| 2 | Victor Hobson | Michigan |
| 3 | B.J. Askew | Michigan |
| 5 | Derek Pagel | Iowa |
| 5 | Matthew Walters | Miami (FL) |
| 6 | Brooks Bollinger | Wisconsin |
| 7 | Dave Yovanovits | Temple |
| 2002 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Bryan Thomas | Alabama-Birmingham |
| 2 | Jon McGraw | Kansas State |
| 3 | Chris Baker | Michigan State |
| 4 | Alan Harper | Fresno State |
| 5 | Jonathan Goodwin | Michigan |
| 2001 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Santana Moss | Miami (FL) |
| 2 | LaMont Jordan | Maryland |
| 3 | Kareem McKenzie | Penn State |
| 4 | Jamie Henderson | Georgia |
| 7 | James Reed | Iowa State |
| 7 | Situpe Peko | Michigan State |
| 2000 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Shaun Ellis | Tennessee |
| 1 | John Abraham | South Carolina |
| 1 | Chad Pennington | Marshall |
| 1 | Anthony Becht | West Virginia |
| 3 | Laveranues Coles | Florida State |
| 5 | Windrell Hayes | USC |
| 6 | Tony Scott | North Carolina State |
| 7 | Richard Seals | Utah |
| 1999 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 2 | Randy Thomas | Mississippi State |
| 3 | David Loverne | San Jose State |
| 4 | Jason Wiltz | Nebraska |
| 5 | Jermaine Jones | Northwest Louisiana |
| 6 | Marc Megna | Richmond |
| 6 | J.P. Machado | Illinois |
| 7 | Ryan Young | Kansas State |
| 7 | J.J. Syvrud | Jamestown |
| 1998 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 2 | Dorian Boose | Washington State |
| 3 | Scott Frost | Nebraska |
| 3 | Kevin Williams | Oklahoma State |
| 4 | Jason Fabini | Cincinnati |
| 5 | Casey Dailey | Northwestern |
| 5 | Doug Karczewski | Virginia |
| 5 | Blake Spence | Oregon |
| 5 | Eric Bateman | Brigham Young |
| 6 | Eric Ogbogu | Maryland |
| 6 | Chris Brazzell | Angelo State |
| 6 | Dustin Johnson | Brigham Young |
| 7 | Lawrence Hart | Southern |
| 1997 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | James Farrior | Virginia |
| 2 | Rick Terry | North Carolina |
| 3 | Dedric Ward | Northern Iowa |
| 4 | Terry Day | Mississippi State |
| 4 | Leon Johnson | North Carolina |
| 5 | Lamont Burns | East Carolina |
| 5 | Raymond Austin | Tennessee |
| 6 | Tim Scharf | Northwestern |
| 6 | Chuck Clements | Houston |
| 7 | Steve Rosga | Colorado |
| 7 | Jason Ferguson | Georgia |
| 1996 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Keyshawn Johnson | USC |
| 2 | Alex Van Dyke | Nevada |
| 3 | Ray Mickens | Texas A&M |
| 5 | Marcus Coleman | Texas Tech |
| 6 | Hugh Hunter | Hampton |
| 7 | Chris Hayes | Washington State |
| 1995 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Kyle Brady | Penn State |
| 1 | Hugh Douglas | Central State (OH) |
| 2 | Matt O'Dwyer | Northwestern |
| 4 | Melvin Hayes | Mississippi State |
| 4 | Tyrone Davis | Virginia |
| 5 | Carl Greenwood | UCLA |
| 6 | Eddie Mason | North Carolina |
| 7 | Curtis Ceaser | Grambling |
| 1994 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Aaron Glenn | Texas A&M |
| 2 | Ryan Yarborough | Wyoming |
| 3 | Lou Benfatti | Penn State |
| 4 | Orlando Parker | Troy State |
| 5 | Horace Morris | Tennessee |
| 6 | Fred Lester | Alabama A&M |
| 7 | Glenn Foley | Boston COLLEGE |
| 1993 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Marvin Jones | Florida State |
| 2 | Coleman Rudolph | Georgia Tech |
| 4 | David Ware | Virginia |
| 5 | Fred Baxter | Auburn |
| 5 | Adrian Murrell | West Virginia |
| 5 | Kenny Shedd | Northern Iowa |
| 6 | Richie Anderson | Penn State |
| 7 | Alec Millen | Georgia |
| 8 | Craig Hentrich | Notre Dame |
| 1992 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Johnny Mitchell | Nebraska |
| 2 | Kurt Barber | USC |
| 3 | Siupeli Malamala | Washington |
| 4 | Keo Coleman | Mississippi State |
| 5 | Cal Dixon | Florida |
| 6 | Glenn Cadrez | Houston |
| 6 | Jeff Blake | East Carolina |
| 8 | Vincent Brownlee | Mississippi |
| 10 | Mario Johnson | Missouri |
| 11 | Eric Boles | Central Washington |
| 1991 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 2 | Browning Nagle | Louisville |
| 3 | Mo Lewis | Georgia |
| 4 | Mark Gunn | Pittsburgh |
| 6 | Blaise Bryant | Iowa State |
| 6 | Mike Riley | Tulane |
| 7 | Doug Parrish | San Francisco State |
| 8 | Tim James | Colorado |
| 9 | Paul Glonek | Arizona State |
| 10 | Al Baker | Kentucky |
| 11 | Rocen Keeton | UCLA |
| 12 | Mark Hayes | Arizona State |
| 1990 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Rob Moore | Syracuse |
| 1 | Blair Thomas | Penn State |
| 2 | Reggie Rembert | West Virginia |
| 3 | Tony Stargell | Tennessee State |
| 4 | Troy Taylor | California |
| 5 | Tony Savage | Washington State |
| 5 | Robert McWright | Texas Christian |
| 6 | Terance Mathis | New Mexico |
| 7 | Dwayne White | Alcorn State |
| 7 | Basil Proctor | West Virginia |
| 8 | Roger Duffy | Penn State |
| 9 | Dale Dawkins | Miami (FL) |
| 10 | Brad Quast | Iowa |
| 11 | Derrick Kelson | Purdue |
| 12 | Darrell Davis | Texas Christian |
| 1989 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Jeff Lageman | Virginia |
| 2 | Dennis Byrd | Tulsa |
| 3 | Joe Mott | Iowa |
| 4 | Ron Stallworth | Auburn |
| 5 | Tony Martin | Mesa State |
| 6 | Marvin Washington | Idaho |
| 6 | Titus Dixon | Troy State |
| 7 | Stevon Moore | Mississippi |
| 8 | Anthony Brown | West Virginia |
| 9 | Pat Marlatt | West Virginia |
| 10 | Adam Bob | Texas A&M |
| 11 | Artie Holmes | Washington State |
| 12 | Willie Snead | Florida |
| 1988 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Dave Cadigan | USC |
| 2 | Terry Williams | Bethune-Cookman |
| 3 | Erik McMillan | Missouri |
| 3 | James Hasty | Washington State |
| 5 | Mike Withycombe | Fresno State |
| 6 | Paul Frase | Syracuse |
| 7 | Gary Patton | Eastern Michigan |
| 8 | Keith Neubert | Nebraska |
| 9 | Ralph Tamm | West Chester (PA) |
| 10 | John Booty | Texas Christian |
| 11 | John Galvin | Boston COLLEGE |
| 12 | Albert Goss | Jackson State |
| 1987 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Roger Vick | Texas A&M |
| 2 | Alex Gordon | Cincinnati |
| 3 | Onzy Elam | Tennessee State |
| 5 | Kirby Jackson | Mississippi State |
| 6 | Tracy Martin | North Dakota |
| 7 | Gerald Nichols | Florida State |
| 8 | Eddie Hunter | Virginia Tech |
| 8 | Mike Rice | Montana |
| 9 | Ron McLean | Fullerton State |
| 10 | Sid Lewis | Penn State |
| 11 | Kirk Timmer | Montana State |
| 12 | Bill Ransdell | Kentucky |
| 1986 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Mike Haight | Iowa |
| 2 | Doug Williams | Texas A&M |
| 3 | Tim Crawford | Texas Tech |
| 4 | Rogers Alexander | Penn State |
| 5 | Ron Hadley | Washington |
| 7 | Bob White | Rhode Island |
| 8 | Robert Duckworth | Southern Mississippi |
| 9 | Nuu Faaola | Hawaii |
| 10 | Carl Carr | North Carolina |
| 11 | Vince Amoia | Arizona State |
| 12 | Sal Cesario | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo |
| 1985 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Al Toon | Wisconsin |
| 2 | Lester Lyles | Virginia |
| 3 | Donnie Elder | Memphis State |
| 4 | Doug Allen | Arizona State |
| 5 | Troy Benson | Pittsburgh |
| 5 | Brian Luft | USC |
| 5 | Tony Smith | San Jose State |
| 6 | Jeff Deaton | Stanford |
| 6 | Rich Miano | Hawaii |
| 8 | Matt Monger | Oklahoma State |
| 9 | Mike Waters | San Diego State |
| 10 | Kerry Glenn | Minnesota |
| 11 | Brad White | Texas Tech |
| 12 | Bill Wallace | Pittsburgh |
| 1984 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Russell Carter | Southern Methodist |
| 1 | Ken Hobart | Idaho |
| 1 | Ron Faurot | Arkansas |
| 2 | Jim Sweeney | Pittsburgh |
| 2 | Jim Sandusky | San Diego State |
| 2 | Glenn Dennison | Miami (FL) |
| 3 | Kyle Clifton | Texas Christian |
| 3 | Turner Gill | Nebraska |
| 4 | Bobby Bell | Missouri |
| 5 | Tron Armstrong | Eastern Kentucky |
| 6 | Tony Paige | Virginia Tech |
| 7 | Harry Hamilton | Penn State |
| 8 | Billy Griggs | Virginia |
| 8 | Bret Wright | Southeastern Louisiana |
| 9 | Tom Baldwin | Tulsa |
| 10 | Ronny Cone | Georgia Tech |
| 11 | Dan Martin | Iowa State |
| 12 | David Robertson | Houston |
| 1983 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Ken O'Brien | California-Davis |
| 2 | Johnny Hector | Texas A&M |
| 3 | JoJo Townsell | UCLA |
| 4 | Wes Howell | California |
| 5 | John Walker | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 6 | Vincent White | Stanford |
| 7 | Darrin Newbold | SW Missouri State |
| 8 | Davlin Mullen | Western Kentucky |
| 9 | Bobby Humphrey | New Mexico State |
| 10 | Danny Fike | Florida |
| 11 | Mike Harmon | Mississippi |
| 12 | Stu Crum | Tulsa |
| 1982 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Bob Crable | Notre Dame |
| 2 | Reggie McElroy | West Texas State |
| 3 | Dwayne Crutchfield | Iowa State |
| 4 | George Floyd | Eastern Kentucky |
| 5 | Mark Jerue | Washington |
| 6 | Lonell Phea | Houston |
| 7 | Tom Coombs | Idaho |
| 8 | Lawrence Texada | Henderson State |
| 9 | Rocky Klever | Montana |
| 10 | Darryl Hemphill | West Texas State |
| 11 | Perry Parmelee | Santa Clara |
| 12 | Tom Carlstrom | Nebraska |
| 1981 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Freeman McNeil | UCLA |
| 2 | Marion Barber | Minnesota |
| 3 | Ben Rudolph | Long Beach State |
| 4 | Al Washington | Ohio State |
| 5 | Tyrone Keys | Mississippi State |
| 6 | John Woodring | Brown |
| 7 | Kenny Neil | Iowa State |
| 8 | Lloyd Jones | Brigham Young |
| 8 | J.C. Watts | Oklahoma |
| 9 | Admiral Dewey Larry | UNLV |
| 10 | Marty Wetzel | Tulane |
| 11 | Ed Gall | Maryland |
| 12 | Mike Moeller | Drake |
| 1980 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Lam Jones | Texas |
| 2 | Darrol Ray | Oklahoma |
| 2 | Ralph Clayton | Michigan |
| 3 | Lance Mehl | Penn State |
| 4 | Jesse Johnson | Colorado |
| 5 | Jim Zidd | Kansas |
| 6 | George Visger | Colorado |
| 6 | Tom Schremp | Wisconsin |
| 7 | Bob Batton | UNLV |
| 7 | Bennie Leverett | Bethune-Cookman |
| 8 | Jeff Dziama | Boston COLLEGE |
| 9 | Joe Peters | Arizona State |
| 10 | Guy Bingham | Montana |
| 11 | James Zachery | Texas A&M |
| 12 | David Dumars | N.E. Louisiana |
| 1979 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Marty Lyons | Alabama |
| 2 | Mark Gastineau | East Central Oklahoma |
| 3 | Donald Dykes | Southeastern Louisiana |
| 4 | Eric Cunningham | Penn State |
| 4 | Johnny Lynn | UCLA |
| 5 | Kelly Kirchbaum | Kentucky |
| 5 | Stan Blinka | Sam Houston State |
| 6 | Bill Dufek | Michigan |
| 7 | Emmett King | Houston |
| 7 | Keith Brown | Minnesota |
| 8 | Marshall Harris | Texas Christian |
| 8 | Willie Beamon | Boise State |
| 9 | Gordy Sprattler | North Dakota State |
| 10 | Steve Sybeldon | North Dakota |
| 10 | Ed McGlasson | Youngstown State |
| 11 | Danny Sanders | Carson-Newman |
| 12 | Paul Darby | Southwest Texas State |
| 1978 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Chris Ward | Ohio State |
| 2 | Mark Merrill | Minnesota |
| 3 | Mickey Shuler | Penn State |
| 4 | Dodie Donnell | Nebraska |
| 5 | Randy Sidler | Penn State |
| 6 | Bobby Jackson | Florida State |
| 6 | Gregg Robinson | Dartmouth |
| 7 | Levi Armstrong | UCLA |
| 7 | James Earley | Michigan State |
| 8 | Derrick Gaffney | Florida |
| 8 | Mike Mock | Texas Tech |
| 8 | Roy Eppes | Clemson |
| 9 | Reggie Grant | Oregon |
| 9 | Neil Hutton | Penn State |
| 10 | Louis Richardson | Florida State |
| 11 | Pat Ryan | Tennessee |
| 12 | Alan Williams | Florida |
| 1977 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Marvin Powell | USC |
| 2 | Wesley Walker | California |
| 3 | Tank Marshall | Texas A&M |
| 4 | Scott Dierking | Purdue |
| 5 | Perry Griggs | Troy State |
| 5 | Gary Gregory | Baylor |
| 6 | Joe Klecko | Temple |
| 7 | Charlie White | Bethune-Cookman |
| 7 | Bob Grupp | Duke |
| 7 | Kevin Long | South Carolina |
| 8 | Dan Alexander | Louisiana State |
| 8 | Ed Thompson | Ohio State |
| 9 | Matt Robinson | Georgia |
| 10 | John Hennessy | Michigan |
| 11 | Dave Butterfield | Nebraska |
| 12 | Phil Gargis | Auburn |
| 12 | Dave Conrad | Maryland |
| 1976 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Richard Todd | Alabama |
| 2 | Shafer Suggs | Ball State |
| 3 | Greg Buttle | Penn State |
| 5 | Steve King | Michigan |
| 6 | Bob Martin | Nebraska |
| 7 | Abdul (Larry) Salaam (Faulk) | Kent State |
| 7 | James Richards | Florida |
| 8 | Joe Davis | USC |
| 8 | Louie Giammona | Utah State |
| 9 | Ronnie Moore | Virginia Military Inst |
| 11 | Lawrence Pillers | Alcorn State |
| 12 | Don Buckey | North Carolina State |
| 12 | Dave Buckey | North Carolina State |
| 14 | Al Gluchoski | West Virginia |
| 15 | Rick Faulk | San Francisco State |
| 16 | James Godwin | Fayetteville |
| 17 | Darwin Willie | Tulane |
| 1975 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 2 | Anthony Davis | USC |
| 3 | Richard Wood | USC |
| 5 | Joe Wysock | Miami (FL) |
| 6 | Tom Alward | Nebraska |
| 8 | James Scott | Henderson J.C. |
| 9 | Everett Taylor | Memphis State |
| 10 | Charles James | Jackson State |
| 11 | Jon Bradford | Central State (OH) |
| 12 | Bert Cooper | Florida State |
| 13 | Dan Spivey | Georgia |
| 14 | Joe Fields | Widener |
| 15 | Brison Manor | Arkansas |
| 16 | Greg Wells | Albany State |
| 17 | Mike Bartoszek | Ohio State |
| 1974 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Carl Barzilawskas | Indiana |
| 2 | Gordon Browne | Boston COLLEGE |
| 3 | Godwin Turk | Southern |
| 3 | Roscoe Word | Jackson State |
| 5 | Gary Baccus | Oklahoma |
| 6 | Bil Wyman | Texas |
| 6 | Wayne Jones | Mississippi State |
| 7 | Burney Veszey | Mississippi |
| 8 | Greg Gantt | Alabama |
| 8 | Larry Lightfoot | Livingston (Ala) |
| 8 | Ron Rydalch | Utah |
| 9 | Robert Burns | Georgia |
| 10 | Sam Baker | Georgia |
| 11 | Eugene Bird | Southern Mississippi |
| 11 | William Buckley | Mississippi State |
| 12 | John Riccz | Duke |
| 13 | John Tate | Jackson State |
| 14 | Greg Fountain | Mississippi State |
| 15 | Willie Brister | Southern |
| 16 | Clarence Jackson | Western Kentucky |
| 17 | Doug Lowrey | Arkansas State |
| 1973 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Burgess Owens | Miami (FL) |
| 2 | Robert Woods | Tennessee State |
| 4 | Bill Gerguson | San Diego State |
| 5 | Bruce Bannon | Penn State |
| 6 | Travis Roach | Texas |
| 6 | Rick Harrell | Clemson |
| 7 | Mike Haggard | South Carolina |
| 8 | Rick Seifert | Ohio State |
| 9 | Roberet Spicer | Indiana |
| 10 | Joe Carbone | Delaware |
| 10 | James Krempin | Texas A&I |
| 11 | David Knight | William & Mary |
| 12 | Gary Puetz | Valparaiso |
| 13 | Robert Parrish | Duke |
| 14 | Joe Schwartz | Toledo |
| 15 | Mahlon Williams | North Carolina State |
| 16 | John Czerwinski | Bowling Green |
| 17 | Jim Foote | Delaware Valley |
| 1972 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Jerome Barkum | Jackson State |
| 1 | Mike Taylor | Michigan |
| 3 | Gary Hammond | Southern Methodist |
| 4 | Ed Galigher | UCLA |
| 5 | Dickie Harris | South Carolina |
| 6 | Joe Jackson | New Mexico State |
| 8 | Marion Lattimore | Kansas State |
| 9 | Jeff Ford | Georgia Tech |
| 10 | Harley Turner | Tennessee-Chattanooga |
| 11 | Robert Stevenson | Tennessee State |
| 12 | John Bjorklund | Princeton |
| 13 | Steve Sullivan | North Texas State |
| 14 | Louis Age | Southwestern Louisiana |
| 15 | Phil Sullivan | Georgia |
| 16 | Gary Kipfmiller | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 17 | Ken Gamble | Fayetteville |
| 1971 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | John Riggins | Kansas |
| 2 | John Mooring | Tampa |
| 3 | Chris Farasopoulos | Brigham Young |
| 4 | Bill Zapalac | Texas |
| 6 | Phil Wise | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 7 | Scott Palmer | Texas |
| 8 | Roy Kirksey | Maryland State |
| 9 | John Curtis | Springfield |
| 10 | Jim Bettis | Michigan |
| 11 | Vernon Studdard | Mississippi |
| 12 | Rich Sowels | Alcorn A&M |
| 13 | John Eggold | Arizona |
| 14 | John Harpring | Michigan |
| 15 | Dan Dyches | South Carolina |
| 16 | Steve Harkey | Georgia Tech |
| 17 | Greg Flaska | Western Michigan |
| 1970 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Steve Tannen | Florida |
| 2 | Richard Caster | Jackson State |
| 3 | Dennis Onkotz | Penn State |
| 4 | John Ebersole | Penn State |
| 5 | Clifford McClain | South Carolina State |
| 5 | Gary Arthus | Miami (OH) |
| 6 | Terry Stewart | Arkansas |
| 7 | James Williams | Virginia State |
| 8 | Jack Porter | Oklahoma |
| 8 | Mark Lomas | Northern Arizona |
| 9 | Ed Bell | Idaho State |
| 10 | Cleve Dickerson | Miami (OH) |
| 11 | Earlie Thomas | Colorado State |
| 12 | Bill Pierson | San Diego State |
| 13 | Walter Groth | Baylor |
| 14 | John Little | Oklahoma State |
| 15 | Tom Bayless | Purdue |
| 16 | Claude Herard | Mississippi |
| 17 | Dick Beard | Kentucky |
| 1969 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Dave Foley | Ohio State |
| 2 | Al Woodall | Duke |
| 4 | Ezell Jones | Minnesota |
| 5 | Chris Gilbert | Texas |
| 6 | Jimmy Jones | Wichita State |
| 7 | Cliff Larson | Houston |
| 8 | Cecil Leonard | Tuskegee |
| 9 | Frank Peters | Ohio |
| 10 | Mike Hall | Alabama |
| 11 | Gary Roberts | Purdue |
| 12 | Mike Battle | USC |
| 13 | Steve O'Neal | Texas A&M |
| 14 | Roger Finnie | Florida A&M |
| 15 | Wayne Stewart | California |
| 16 | George Nock | Morgan State |
| 17 | Fred Zirkie | Duke |
| 1968 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Lee White | Weber State |
| 2 | Steve Thompson | Washington |
| 3 | Sam Walton | East Texas State |
| 4 | Gary Magner | USC |
| 5 | Lee Jacobsen | Kearney State |
| 7 | Oscar Lubke | Ball State |
| 8 | Bob Taylor | Maryland-Eastern Shore |
| 8 | Jim Richards | Virginia Tech |
| 8 | Karl Henke | Tulsa |
| 9 | Gary Houser | Oregon State |
| 10 | Mike D'Amato | Hofstra |
| 11 | Henry Owens | Weber State |
| 12 | Ray Hayes | Toledo |
| 13 | Tom Myslinski | Maryland |
| 14 | Harvey Nairn | Southern |
| 15 | Ronnie Ehrig | Texas |
| 16 | Tom Bilotta | Adams State |
| 17 | Myles Strasser | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 1967 | ||
| ROUND | NAME | COLLEGE |
| 1 | Paul Seiler | Notre Dame |
| 2 | Rich Sheron | Washington State |
| 3 | Dennis Randall | Oklahoma State |
| 3 | Henry King | Utah State |
| 4 | Julian Gray | Grambling |
| 5 | Louis Jackson | Grambling |
| 6 | Jeff Richardson | Michigan State |
| 7 | John Elliott | Texas |
| 8 | Gene Bledsoe | Texas |
| 9 | Ray Scott | Prairie View |
| 10 | Raymond Brown | Alcorn A&M |
| 11 | Herb Slattery | Delaware |
| 12 | Randy Rasmussen | Kearney (Neb.) |
| 13 | Jack Emmer | Rutgers |
| 14 | Mike Stromberg | Temple |
| 15 | Jack Schweberger | Vermont |
| 16 | Doug Archibald | Tennessee |
| 17 | Bob Biletnikoff | Miami (FL) |